Showing posts with label Abraham. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Abraham. Show all posts

Monday, July 22, 2024

Sacrifice and Salvation


 Preached at Silverton Friends Church

April 28, 2024

William Blake wrote a poem: “To God / If you have form’d a circle to go into / Go into it yourself and see how you would do.” This is exactly what God did in the Son, Jesus. Jesus came into the world, our circle, and we can see how God did and what God did in that circle.


Central to Christian belief is that God loved the world in this way: Jesus came as God’s only begotten Son to seek for and save the lost so that they might not perish. Jesus said that he came not to condemn the world, but so that the world through him could be saved. He was killed for his message of inclusive grace and and for teaching the need to align one’s heart and words and deeds and for his insistence that he would not play the game of power so dear to human beings.


Jesus’s choice to embrace sacrifice and the result that we now are at one with God have been preached around the world.  The way we explain to ourselves why Jesus died at the hands of human beings has enormous significance for how we view God and ourselves and our mutual relationship. I think that each explanation can cite passages from the Bible in support. The discussion, and even enmity, around these explanations underlines the centrality of sacrifice for Christians. Some Christians are uncomfortable and perhaps even queasy about the idea of such a sacrifice being necessary. So I want to think with you about the distinction between being a sacrifice and being a victim, and spoiler alert, the distinction centers on agency.


Probably most obvious is that a victim suffers without having chosen it.  I think about the near death of Isaac in the Old Testament.  The story goes like this: after decades of waiting for a son with his wife Sarah, God sent her a son.  Now, what often goes unsaid is that Abraham had an older son with Sarah’s slave, Hagar, which was apparently an acceptable version of surrogacy in those times.  Ishmael could have inherited, but he would have been known to be the son of the slave. But God showed up to Abraham and promised that Sarah, in her 90s, would have a baby, too.  And she did, recognizing the joke on her by calling him Isaac, which means laughter.  She forced Abraham to banish Hagar and Ishmael so Isaac would be the only son, and he did. In this case, both Hagar and Ishmael were victims of Sarah’s jealousy and Abraham’s spinelessness.  But God stepped in and met Hagar and led her and Ishmael to water and safety. You can read this whole story in Genesis 12-23.


Then, when Isaac was old enough to help carry firewood, God told Abraham to take him up on a mountain and offer him up to God at that place. I have wondered whether this took place in a culture that practiced human sacrifice, but I don’t know. Abraham followed God’s instructions, even proceeding to the point of tying Isaac on top of the firewood, lifting his hand with the knife in it. God halted the proceedings at that point, saying, “Now I know that you are in awe of God—you have not withheld your son, your only one, from me.” And God provided a ram for the sacrifice instead of the boy.  


If Abraham had gone through with the offering, he would have sacrificed, but Isaac would have been the victim, having had no choice in the matter. However, like his banished brother Ishmael, Isaac got to witness God taking care of him when God provided the ram in his place. This is God’s repeated posture in the scripture—identifying with the victim, caring for the victim.


I’ve speculated about this story more than once, wondering why an omniscient God had to find out whether Abraham would be obedient, wondering if instead Abraham had to find out whether he would be obedient. God only knows what lessons God wanted Abraham to draw from that incident, but it’s likely Isaac did not draw the same ones. I’ve wondered how Isaac viewed his father after this event, and how Isaac viewed his father’s God. I’ve thought about how it connects up with Jesus saying that anyone who loves father and mother and wife and children more than they love Jesus is not worthy of him (Matthew 10:37-39). Or even more shockingly, Whoever comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple.(Luke 14:26, NRSV). These passages, particularly the reference to hatred, make me so uncomfortable. I had to try to soften them, and the word itself does not actually permit softening.  So we have to look at how Jesus behaved as he followed the Spirit of God to help us understand. What does it look like to live putting everything second to God’s Spirit?


Jesus had no wife or children, though people like to speculate, and the possibility is that because his conception was irregular, he was in something of a marginalized position in Jewish society. He did have a mother, and we can look at how he treated her in order to understand what he said.  At the age of 12, which is the Jewish age of manhood, he let her know he would put God’s business first. He listened to her and granted her request at the marriage in Cana, turning the water into wine, but he pushed back, rebuking her a little.  When she came to see him, worried he was in danger of losing mind and life, he refused to go out to see her, saying, “My mother and family are those who hear the word of God and do it.” But when he was dying, he committed her welfare to the disciple he loved, John, who from that day took her into his family. He let her know that obedience to God was top priority, making Mom happy was second at most, but he cared for her.


Further, I want to point out that Jesus also called to account those religious people who let their parents suffer while they designated big sums for the temple, and he condemned those who made it hard for children to approach and trust him and his Father. He said that what people do to the little ones they do to him, so all that has to be carried in the mind while meditating on the absoluteness of the call of God on our lives. Following God first does not mean carelessness about those we love or cruelty to our neighbors.


Jesus made his all or nothing statements in reference to the decision to follow him, so we need to observe closely and intelligently what Jesus did with his life.  Crucially, he depended always on God to tell him what to do and how to do it.  “I do only what I see the Father doing,” he said.


One way Jesus resembled his Father is in looking beyond surfaces to see what another human being is prioritizing. He looked at the rich young ruler and saw that, despite his goodness, what he held as a priority was riches. So he said, “Give them away and come follow me.” He looked at Peter, Andrew, James, and John, and saw that they prioritized their family business and heritage as fishermen. So he said, “Come follow me and I’ll make you fishers for human beings.” He looked at Nicodemus and saw he prioritized his age and intelligence and knowledge of the law. So he said, “You must start over as a new baby in order to follow me.” He looked at Judas and saw he prioritized political expediency and personal advantage. So he said, “Make your choice about what to do and choose quickly.” He looked at the woman caught in the act of adultery and saw she prioritized being desired and desiring. So he said, “Go and sin no more.” He looked at Pharisees and saw them basking in superiority about their knowledge and observance of the law. So he said, “You exempt yourselves from the spirit of the law by following your interpretation of the letter, and you make it impossible for others to measure up. Unless you change direction, you are the children of the devil.” He looked at Zacchaeus and saw that he prioritized getting to see Jesus at the cost of personal dignity. So he said, “Come down and I’ll eat with you.” And Zacchaeus said, “I’ll repay everyone I’ve defrauded and pay damages as well.” 


Some of these people indeed set aside what they had made central to their lives and identities, choosing to follow Jesus. Occasionally they expressed the feeling that they hoped this would pay off tangibly somehow, and occasionally Jesus pointed out that how people treated him was a good indication of how they would treat those who follow him.


When Jesus chose to allow himself to be arrested and crucified, he sacrificed himself despite all his human fear of pain, his ordinary desire for life and happiness. In the garden he sweated drops of blood as he contemplated his near future of torture and death, and on the cross he cried out his sense of abandonment by God. He protested against pain and death and aloneness, but he held fast to his intention because it brought and brings good for us. His ultimate act of agency was choosing to forgive his torturers. Forgiveness reclaims agency and is so good for our souls when we come to a place where we find it possible.


Jesus said that there is no greater love than this, that a person will lay down their life for a friend.  Paul said that some might be brave enough to die for a good person. but we know God really loves us all, because Christ died for, as Paul puts it, the ungodly (Romans 5).  Jesus said that he himself is the good shepherd, and what makes him good is that he lays down his life for the sheep, unlike the hired hand, who runs for his life (John 10). We are the sheep of God’s pasture (Ps. 121). What we learn by observing and listening to Jesus is that God has acted and eternally acts sacrificially for our good. 


Jesus was clear that there is a cost to discipleship, and that top priority would always have to be listening to what God’s Spirit says and doing what God’s Spirit says to do. And Jesus warns us not to judge others for how well they’re doing this hard work, noting that the severity of our judgment will rebound onto us. 


God always knew that the only way to make clear how much God loves us is to show us God’s Son entering into our world to be a willing sacrifice, enduring the results of human choices. It’s as if God was willing to go through the experience Abraham was spared in order to cement our understanding of how much God is committed to loving us. This kind of sacrifice was and is chosen by the one who will be sacrificed. Because of what Jesus chose, we see that we can trust God with our whole selves and lives. 


Thursday, August 4, 2022

Jesus and His Bible, Part 12

The God Who Is 

This chapter 12 of Mark describes Jesus in one confrontation after another. After the one about the unfaithful vine-growers, the Pharisees and Herodians (unlikely allies) tried to trap Jesus about paying taxes to Rome, and then the Sadducees came up with a long story about a woman who married one brother after another until she finally followed the seventh in death.  I speculate that this was one of those perennial points of debate between the Sadducees, who did not believe in the resurrection of the dead, and the Pharisees, who did. Their participation together in trying to trap Jesus reveals that in their time as well as ours, politics made strange bedfellows. (Also, to me, it resembles the question of how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.)


Jesus answered first by saying to the Sadducees, “You don’t know the scriptures nor do you know the power of God.” Once again, hardly conciliatory. This was a confrontation with the priestly establishment who were in positions of political as well as religious power, and Jesus described them as ignorant of their scriptures and of what God can do. (He went on to say that resurrected people are no longer involved in marriage, and are like angels, a fascinating statement, but beyond what we’re working on here.)


And then he said this: “But regarding the fact that the dead rise again, have you not read in the book of Moses, in the passage about the burning bush, how God spoke to him, saying, ‘I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob’?” (Mark 12:26). Again, “Have you not read”—Jesus asked those in charge of religious observance if they were even reading their scriptures.  


Jesus asked them a good question which goes right back to the rescue of the Israelites from slavery in Egypt. The question exposed their superficial reading of the scriptures that were basic to their national identity, their claim of being chosen by God. 


The context for the quotation is the story of Moses and the slavery in Egypt of the Hebrew people.  Moses was born at a time in Egypt when the Pharaoh had decreed that all Hebrew boy babies were to be killed at birth. The heroic midwives Shiprah and Puah refused to obey the edict and instead reported to Pharaoh that Hebrew women delivered too quickly to need their services. Then Pharaoh required his own people to throw Hebrew sons into the river. When Moses was born, his mother hid him for three months, then placed him into a small woven and waterproofed boat and floated him on the river. 


Pharaoh’s daughter took him out of the water and had compassion on him, even knowing him to be a little Hebrew boy.  His birth mother became his wet-nurse for pay, and the princess adopted him and named him Moses. Moses grew up in safety, even privilege, though he knew of his Hebrew origin, and when he saw an Egyptian beating a Hebrew slave, he killed the Egyptian and hid the body.  The Hebrews denied his authority and Pharaoh wanted to kill him, so he fled the country to Midian, where he found water, a wife, and a job as a shepherd.  


Some time later, he saw a bush burning without being burnt to ashes, and he went to investigate. God called him by name from within the burning bush.


It is worth wondering what Moses’s exact religious upbringing had been. It seems likely that  his mother taught him about Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph, and the God they worshiped. It seems likely also that the princess taught him about Ra and Isis and Osiris, and the rest of the Egyptian pantheon. But this is the flashpoint of his understanding who his God is and will be going forward.


“I am the God of your father—the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob” (Exodus 3:6). This reminds Moses of his immediate father in Egypt as well as of his ancestors. So much history is embedded in those three names, so much of their personal relationships with this God. I think of Abraham leaving his homeland to wander at the word of God; of Abraham taking his son Isaac to be a sacrifice at God’s command; at Isaac being rescued from that sacrifice by the messenger of God; at Jacob running from the consequences of his duplicity only to be met by God in a dream, and then years later on the way back home wrestling with God’s messenger into permanent lameness. So much that could be explored, too much for this post. All of their stories are implicit in Jesus’s quotation, and he requires his opponents to look at the history of personal relationship and responsibility to God embodied in those patriarchs.


The emphasis on “I am”  in the list is an insistence on the present tense of God.  It also looks forward to the point in Moses’s story when he asks, “Who shall I say has sent me?” The reply, I AM WHO I AM, doubly emphasizes God’s irreducibility and presence, God’s creative and sustaining power.  


Further, Jesus went on to say that “God is not the God of the dead, but the God of the living.” He linked this to an affirmation that the dead are alive with God, which his Sadducee questioners denied. But it is more profound even than that. 


What else could this have meant to Jesus’s hearers?  I think it meant that his questioners needed to look at their own personal relationships with the God of their patriarchs: each of them had had personal encounters with the “I AM WHO I AM” who spoke to Moses.  They needed to acknowledge God being immediately present in the moment in which they were questioning Jesus. They needed to admit God’s claims on their obedience and loyalty. But what they did was take refuge in tradition and traditional understandings that allowed them to maintain their status quo. This is a lesson for all of us.

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

We're Marching to Zion

Preached at Northwest Yearly Meeting of Friends 
July 23, 2012

After the assassination of civil rights leader, Medgar Evers in 1963 , Bob Dylan wrote a song called “Only a Pawn in Their Game.” In that song, Dylan admits that a single white man pulled the trigger that killed Medgar Evers, but he blames the action on power structures of the time—education, law, politics—that exploited the poor white man’s need to be better than someone.  Racism was taught and used to support and advance the powers and principalities.  My anxiety about American Christians is that we may be pawns in someone else’s wicked game.

What I want to talk about is the Biblical teaching that at a deep level Christians don’t actually fit in, not in America, not in any system, because we belong to a different city, a different kingdom or nation, and our first loyalty is to the leader there—our Lord Jesus Christ.  This theme of faithful homelessness runs through the whole Bible and through our best moments as Quakers, and as we take a look at it, we can see how we are to pray for the nations of our world, and particularly our own nation, for the cities and states we live in, and for our government and how we are to live peacefully with our neighbors.

First, we pray for God’s mercy on those eligible for judgment.

Our first faithful exile is Abraham, who left his home city to follow God’s leading into a land God promised to his children.  Abraham never owned any of this land except for the tomb in which he buried his wife Sarah.  Instead, he was a nomad on it, and his sojourn there is a visual parable for our existence in this world that groans for the unveiling of the children of God, for redemption.  We also are nomads.

Hebrews 11:8-10
By faith Abraham obeyed when he was called to set out for a place that he was to receive as an inheritance; and he set out, not knowing where he was going. By faith he stayed for a time in the land he had been promised, as in a foreign land, living in tents…

For he looked forward to the city that has foundations, whose architect and builder is God.

So, like Abraham, we are in two realities at the same time:  this world and the Kingdom of God. We are nomads in this world because we are looking for the City of God, because we are citizens of the Kingdom of God.

We are in this world, but it doesn’t own us.  How do we then relate to this world?

Genesis 18 tells us one of the ways Abraham related to his world.  God shared with Abraham that judgment was going to fall on Sodom and Gomorrah, and Abraham was struck with grief.  He had gone to war on behalf of the king of Sodom, and they had a sort of mutual respect.  Abraham’s nephew Lot had moved into Sodom and done well there. 

So Abraham talked with God.  He interceded for Sodom.  What if there are 50 righteous people there, will you still destroy it?  What if there are 45, 40, 30, 20?  What if there are 10?  Each time, God relented, agreeing with Abraham that if there were finally only 10 righteous persons in Sodom, he would spare the city.  You know the story, and how there were not even 10 righteous persons there.  But what I want to point to is how Abraham grieved over the world of which he was not even a citizen, how he prayed for mercy for it. The fact that judgment fell on Sodom asks us to believe that an omniscient God knows better than we how to judge and when to judge. What we learn, however, is Abraham prayed for his world, and we ought also to pray for ours. 

Pray for the nation’s well-being, even if they worship idols.

In the history of Israel, after they became the owners of the land promised to Abraham, they were faithless and worshiped things other than God.  God’s way of getting their attention was to uproot them from home and send them as captives into Babylon. They could live with their families in homes there, but they were not free to leave.  They deeply missed their homeland, and some who claimed to speak for God promised them that their captivity would be short.  But the prophet Jeremiah called those prophets liars and said to the Jews living in Babylon:

Jeremiah 29: Thus says the Lord of hosts, the God of Israel to all the exiles I have sent from Jerusalem to Babylon: Build houses and live in them; plant gardens, eat the produce. Marry and have children; let those children marry and bear children. Multiply there, and do not decrease.  But seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the Lord on its behalf, for in its welfare, you will find your welfare.

Interesting, isn’t it?  Here they are under house arrest, so to speak, with freedom to go to the marketplace but not freedom to go home to Israel.  They are surrounded by idol-worshipers, and they cannot carry out their temple worship.  Yet Jeremiah counsels them to settle down, have families, and pray for the welfare of Babylon. 

Because we can vote, we feel we have some control over the direction of the nation, and half of us are angry every election to see that God lost again. Many American Christians feel like this country has become a place where we are exiles. We mourn that our nation has no moral center and is worshiping idols.  What should we do as exiles in our own country?

 We should pray for things to go well.  Pray for peace, pray for prosperity, no matter who is the president or on the Supreme Court or the governor of our state or the mayor of our town.  In its prosperity and peace is our own, says Jeremiah. And during a peaceful exile, we can raise families who obey the true God and are faithful to him. 

This advice to the Jews in Babylon runs counter to our culture wars.  Instead of badmouthing Democrats or Republicans, American Christians can and ought to band together to pray for the well-being of this nation and the nations where other Christians live, in fact for the whole global village.

Like Sodom, Babylon was judged by God, who is, after all, omniscient about the timing of judgment. This is another lesson we can take away.

Obey the laws and pay your taxes; give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and give to God what belongs to God.

Those Christians who lived in Rome, right under the Emperor’s nose, could be hauled into court and required to swear an oath of loyalty that included a statement that the Emperor was divine.  Into this context, St. Paul wrote the following:

Romans 13: Let every person be subject to the governing authorities; for there is no authority except from God, and those authorities that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore whoever resists authority resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment. For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Do you wish to have no fear of the authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive its approval; for it is God’s servant for your good. But if you do what is wrong, you should be afraid, for the authority does not bear the sword in vain! It is the servant of God to execute wrath on the wrongdoer. Therefore one must be subject not only because of wrath but also because of conscience. For the same reason you also pay taxes, for the authorities are God’s servants, busy with this very thing. Pay to all what is due them—taxes to whom taxes are due, revenue to whom revenue is due, respect to whom respect is due, honor to whom honor is due.

This reminds me of Quaker history.  During the English Civil War, Quakers were always in trouble. Even though they lived in a Christian nation, they confronted the principality within political power every time they refused to take the loyalty oath to whoever was in power that day, whether to Oliver Cromwell or to King Charles II.  As a people of prayer, Quakers felt compelled to act on the words of Jesus to “swear not at all.”  But, like Paul invoking his Roman citizenship, Fox and Margaret Fell and others visited Cromwell and later the King to plead for justice, for the magistrate’s sword to fall on evil doers, not on peaceful people who belonged to the kingdom of God and did no harm to their neighbors. 

St Paul goes on to write about our posture toward those who share our space on this earth:

Owe no one anything except to love one another; for the one who loves another has fulfilled the law. The commandments about adultery, murder, theft, coveting and any other commandment are summed up in this word, “Love your neighbor as yourself.” Love does no wrong to a neighbor; therefore, love is the fulfilling of the law.  Let us live honorably as in the day, laying aside the works of darkness, wearing the armor of light. Let us not live in reveling and drunkenness, debauchery and licentiousness, quarreling and jealousy. Instead put on the Lord Jesus Christ and don’t try to gratify every desire.

The Palestine Jesus came to was not independent, but was a territory in the Roman Empire.  Significantly, the Roman armies as they occupied all these territories also put an end to local conflicts and wars, so that there was order where before there was danger and chaos.  And yet some among the occupied peoples would cheerfully have traded the Pax Romana for the right to be their own nation with their own government.  In the midst of the chosen people in their promised homeland, Jesus responded to Pilate’s question “Are you the king of the Jews?” with this: “My kingdom is not from this world. If my kingdom were from this world, my followers would be fighting to keep me from being handed over to the Jews. But as it is, my kingdom is not from here.” Pilate asked him, “So you are a king?” Jesus answered, “You say that I am a king. For this I was born, and for this I came into the world, to testify to the truth. Everyone who belongs to the truth listens to my voice.”(John 18:33-38)

Jesus is the king and Jesus is the truth: John 14:6 I am he in whom the truth is summed up and impersonated. And the judgment is that Jesus came into the world to light it up and people preferred the darkness to the light because he exposed their evil. May we take the opportunity of meeting Jesus to move closer to the light rather than running from it.

We don’t declare war on other people, whether the war is cultural or physical.  Just as the kingdom of God is invisible but real within and among us, so also are the enemies of our souls.  And the battlefield is prayer.

Put on the whole armor of God in order to stand against the wiles of the Devil, for we struggle not against flesh and blood enemies but against the rulers (arche, as in archetypes), the authorities (the judges), the cosmic rulers of darkness (blindness, ignorance of spiritual truths) in our time, the spiritual forces of evil in heavenly places…stand therefore, having protected your guts with the belt of truth and your heart with the breastplate of righteousness (integrity in thought, word, deed), wearing whatever readies you to proclaim the gospel of peace (harmony and tranquility between people and between people and God), holding the shield of faith and wearing the helmet of salvation, armed with the sword of the Spirit, speaking the word of God.  Then pray in the Spirit at all times in every prayer and pleading.  Stay alert and always persevere in pleading for all the saints.

Beloved, let us love each other, for love comes from God and everyone who loves is born of God and knows God; those who do not love, do not know God for God IS love. 1 John 4:7, 8.

Our city is not an earthly city, not an earthly kingdom or nation. The foundation, the blueprints and buildings all come from God who is truth; God sent Jesus who is the Truth,; Jesus sends the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of truth, who will guide us into all truth.  And the truth sets us free to live as citizens of the kingdom of God.

Like Abraham, we are called by God to live by faith, waiting for the City of God to be given to us, the new Jerusalem that John saw descending from heaven. In that city, all tears are wiped away, there is healing for all nations, and we share in the wedding supper of the Lamb of God.  Is it here yet?  Here and there we catch gleams of it, and we cannot get enough.  This is the city where God is the light, where Jesus is the King, and where the drama of salvation has its fulfillment.

Jesus said that we act out of our hearts, our imaginations.  George Fox talked about Sodom as a parable for the wicked imagination that dwells within each of us. We know our own need for mercy. What if we pray for mercy for our neighbors when their behaviors scandalize or repel us?  Like us, they may also have a part of their hearts hungering for God.  We can pray for the same mercy for them as we hope for ourselves.  

Our prayers for the world we live in, to which we don’t belong, are for the well-being of those who do belong to it.  We recognize that God has set up governments to keep peace, to limit wrongdoing, and God expects us to be good citizens, paying our taxes, paying fees, respecting and honoring the authorities.  Yet because Jesus is our King and we belong in and to his kingdom, we are not pawns in their game.  We are to owe others only love.  Love fulfills the law.  When we live according to love, we discipline the desires of our bodies and the lusts of our imaginations.  

We fight the evil around us through prayer, as Ephesians teaches us.  We wear the protection provided by God’s grace. When we speak or act the prophetic word of God, we carry into the enemy territory the good news of peace and harmony between humans and between humans and God.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYyQKKy2TTo

Come ye that love the Lord and let your joys be known
Join in a song with sweet accord, (2X)
And thus surround the throne (2X)

We’re marching to Zion, beautiful, beautiful Zion,
We’re marching upward to Zion, the beautiful city of God.

Let those refuse to sing who never knew our God,
But children of the heavenly King (2X)
May speak their joys abroad,(2X)

Then let our songs abound, and every tear be dry;
We’re marching through Immanuel’s ground (2X)
To fairer worlds on high (2X)